Veganism seeks to exclude all forms of animal exploitation and cruelty as much as possible.
So, is keeping ornamental fish in a tank or aquarium consistent with vegan ethics? There are good arguments on both sides.
On one hand, most vegans keep pets like dogs and cats while maintaining a vegan diet and lifestyle.
In this sense, keeping fish as pets is not fundamentally different than having a vegan dog or cat.
However, there are some important considerations with fish.
Vegan Arguments Against Fishkeeping
Confined Spaces
Even the most expansive home aquariums restrict fish to a fraction of their natural habitat size.
Bettas, for instance, occupy rice paddy ecosystems spanning thousands of square meters in the wild. Captivity typically limits them to under 10 liters.
These cramped conditions restrict crucial environmental enrichment behaviors like plotting out territory, forming social hierarchies, and exploring various micro-ecosystems.
The spatial confinement will cause chronic stress.
Breeding and Culling
Mass-producing fish for the ornamental trade involves systematically exploiting reproductive processes at commercial scales.
Breeders often cull less marketable fry to generate desired color varieties.
Discarded juvenile fish tend to face premature death from callous methods like asphyxiation or pH/temperature shock.
The systematic conditioning of female stock to produce litters aligned with trait-based demand, only to dispose of “waste” progeny, contradicts vegan philosophical positions on commodifying sentient beings.
Environmental Impact
The ornamental industry proved so environmentally taxing that the EU now regulates the importation of wild-caught specimens with sustainability criteria.
Cyanide fishing continues illegally while habitat erosion and biodiversity threats persist via increased competition from non-native introductions.
Each instance of participation in the trade subtly enables further ecological damage. Avoiding complicity requires abstaining from purchases.
Commodification
The sheer diversity of ornamental species – over 4,000 types of freshwater fish alone – indicates the vast scope of piscine commodification for home decoration purposes.
Reducing autonomous, naturally social animals to chattel valued only for aesthetic appeal or novelty deeply offends vegan ethical positions.
From breeding through sale, the ornamental trade reduces fish to mere commodities valued exclusively by our whims.
Vegan Counterarguments Supporting Fishkeeping
On the other hand, some vegans make sensible counterarguments:
Proper care
With sufficient tank space, high-quality filtration, live planting, appropriate stocking density, and attentive maintenance, captive fish can thrive nearly equivalently to their wild counterparts.
Custom-designed, 150+ gallon enclosures offer enriched habitats accommodating complex behaviors.
While spatial restrictions apply to even capacious aquariums, optimized conditions may adequately provide for welfare absent severe deprivation or distress.
Rescues
Adopting unwanted fish from shelters, retailers, or former owners offers perhaps the most ethical way for vegans to keep fish while saving lives.
Over 90% of juvenile cichlids, 50% of adult goldfish, and 30% of various tropical species purchased for home aquariums end up abandoned.
Ill-informed owners discard unsustainable “pets” bought on impulse.
Education
Public aquariums accredited for exceptional animal care standards promote marine ecology conservation to millions of visitors annually.
Enthusiast hobbyists also raise awareness on sustainability issues and proper fish keeping.
Countering public misconceptions about capacity for suffering may, over time, inform reforms in ethics-based regulations.
So, mindful aquarism could indirectly help reduce environmental and direct harm.
Final Thoughts
Considering all the factors discussed in this article, you must determine whether the potential harms outweigh the enjoyment and responsibility of properly caring for aquarium fish.
With mindful stocking, maintenance, and environmental awareness, fishkeeping can align with veganism for some.
Leave a comment